Another gas stove, another passaround. The
MSR Reactor says it is the "Fastest, Most Efficient, All Condition Stove System" - reason enough for me to have a closer look at it, and organize a passaround!

In its box.
Lets start with the important bits:
Lid: 48 g
Stove: 176 g
Pot: 256 g
Cloth: 5 g
Full 230 g Gas canister, 4 season mix: 364 g
Makes a total of 485 g for the stove, pot, lid and cloth, or 849 g for the set with a full 230 g gas canister, which fits into the pot together with the stove. I don't put this down as ultralight, but it is light - especially in comparison with a Trangia, which is usually double the weight for the small set. MSR says the pot is fine for 1 - 3 persons, that is realistic if you eat ready-made meals and all you need is boiling water.
The lid has a handy rubber grip and a steam hole, and the pot a long handle. It is a 1,7 l pot and has markings on the inside, but the max fill is 1 l which is a bit odd - maybe MSR wanted to make sure that nothing boils over. It also has an internal heat exchanger. The stove is one solid, well-made piece and is screwed on the canister, with a tight fit. The Flame Adjuster has a piece of rubber, so you won't burn your fingers and it makes for easy operating with gloves.

The pot closes tight with stove, cloth and a gas canister inside.

The stove nestled on top of the cloth in the pot.
It is a nice compact system, and is supposed to be brutally fast - it should take between three and five minutes to boil a liter of water in real world conditions - something I will test in the upcoming video. I think it is an excellent stove for those who need boiling water, and need it fast with as little fussing as possible. If you're planning to cook and simmer, I believe that should be possible as well - you can adjust the heat output. It also has the integrated wind screen with the pot, as well as the heat exchanger, a well thought out system if you ask me.

Pot and the stove on a canister, ready for action.

The whole system set up.
I'd like to pass the MSR Reactor set around to five different readers and have them test it. If you're a total newbie to gas stoves like me or a seasoned veteran, anyone can apply for a test of the set. So how does this work? I send out the set to the first reader, and he gets to play around with it for two weeks. You need to have access to gas cartridges (I can't send those) and you need to be willing to pay the postage to send it to the next person, but besides that its completely free to you and allows you to test the stove without shelling out the money first. After your two weeks of playing you send the set forward to the next in line, and drop me a short email about what you thought of the set, which will be published here on the blog. In that way we can collect different viewpoints on the MSR Reactor, see how it performs in different environments, and get a nice review together.
You want to take part in the Passaround? Great! What you need to do is leave a comment underneath (preferrably not anonymous), and next week Tuesday (13th of April) around noon I will randomly pick the five people who get to test the MSR Reactor. While I'd love to have this Passaround open to everyone, sending packages, even small ones like these, is expensive, so I'd would like to limit it this time to Europe, with a preference for Scandinavia and the Baltics. Before you hit the comment button, I'd like to remember you - you should be able to get a gas cartridge for the test in your town, you need to be willing to pay the shipping costs to the next person, and you're fine with sending me a short statement of your opinion with a photo or two. If that sounds like a good deal to you, please comment!
And in case you say "That's all I needed to know, thanks!" and want to buy one right away,
Ultralight Outdoor Gear has a good offer for the MSR Reactor at the moment, and their service is outstanding, so a good recommendation if you don't want to wait for the outcome of the Passaround.
Another gas stove, another passaround. The
MSR Reactor says it is the "Fastest, Most Efficient, All Condition Stove System" - reason enough for me to have a closer look at it, and organize a passaround!

In its box.
Lets start with the important bits:
Lid: 48 g
Stove: 176 g
Pot: 256 g
Cloth: 5 g
Full 230 g Gas canister, 4 season mix: 364 g
Makes a total of 485 g for the stove, pot, lid and cloth, or 849 g for the set with a full 230 g gas canister, which fits into the pot together with the stove. I don't put this down as ultralight, but it is light - especially in comparison with a Trangia, which is usually double the weight for the small set. MSR says the pot is fine for 1 - 3 persons, that is realistic if you eat ready-made meals and all you need is boiling water.
The lid has a handy rubber grip and a steam hole, and the pot a long handle. It is a 1,7 l pot and has markings on the inside, but the max fill is 1 l which is a bit odd - maybe MSR wanted to make sure that nothing boils over. It also has an internal heat exchanger. The stove is one solid, well-made piece and is screwed on the canister, with a tight fit. The Flame Adjuster has a piece of rubber, so you won't burn your fingers and it makes for easy operating with gloves.

The pot closes tight with stove, cloth and a gas canister inside.

The stove nestled on top of the cloth in the pot.
It is a nice compact system, and is supposed to be brutally fast - it should take between three and five minutes to boil a liter of water in real world conditions - something I will test in the upcoming video. I think it is an excellent stove for those who need boiling water, and need it fast with as little fussing as possible. If you're planning to cook and simmer, I believe that should be possible as well - you can adjust the heat output. It also has the integrated wind screen with the pot, as well as the heat exchanger, a well thought out system if you ask me.

Pot and the stove on a canister, ready for action.

The whole system set up.
I'd like to pass the MSR Reactor set around to five different readers and have them test it. If you're a total newbie to gas stoves like me or a seasoned veteran, anyone can apply for a test of the set. So how does this work? I send out the set to the first reader, and he gets to play around with it for two weeks. You need to have access to gas cartridges (I can't send those) and you need to be willing to pay the postage to send it to the next person, but besides that its completely free to you and allows you to test the stove without shelling out the money first. After your two weeks of playing you send the set forward to the next in line, and drop me a short email about what you thought of the set, which will be published here on the blog. In that way we can collect different viewpoints on the MSR Reactor, see how it performs in different environments, and get a nice review together.
You want to take part in the Passaround? Great! What you need to do is leave a comment underneath (preferrably not anonymous), and next week Tuesday (13th of April) around noon I will randomly pick the five people who get to test the MSR Reactor. While I'd love to have this Passaround open to everyone, sending packages, even small ones like these, is expensive, so I'd would like to limit it this time to Europe, with a preference for Scandinavia and the Baltics. Before you hit the comment button, I'd like to remember you - you should be able to get a gas cartridge for the test in your town, you need to be willing to pay the shipping costs to the next person, and you're fine with sending me a short statement of your opinion with a photo or two. If that sounds like a good deal to you, please comment!
And in case you say "That's all I needed to know, thanks!" and want to buy one right away,
Ultralight Outdoor Gear has a good offer for the MSR Reactor at the moment, and their service is outstanding, so a good recommendation if you don't want to wait for the outcome of the Passaround.
MSR Reactor - Passaround
Hmmmm, is this MSR's (slightly heavier) answer to the Jetboil Flash?
ReplyDeleteFar too much for summer and maybe not quite enough capacity for melting snow in winter unless you're on your own. Also I'd be more inclined to look at an inverted cannister if the temperature really dropped. Interesting though, especially the heat exchanger. Will the savings in efficiency outweigh the weight of just carrying more fuel? Look forward to hearing about people's experiences.
Once again I must commend this pass-around initiative. It's a great way to gather subjective views of a product then combine the results.
I'm in.
ReplyDeleteHi Henrik, I'd be interested in giving it a go.
ReplyDeleteHi, I'm also interested.
ReplyDeleteI saw this in use while I hiked a six day trip in Yosemite. I brought my Jetboil PCS (Personal Cooking System) along, and the other group brought their MSR Reactor.
ReplyDeleteHendrik's weight measurements speak clearly enough, let me instead reinforce how nicely this is put together. As mentioned in the review, the small plastic bits, and sturdy workmanship make for a nice package. It is a quality built product that wasn't needlessly overbuilt.
The reactor was used for three people, whereas I alone used my Jetboil. The Jetboil is best for one person as its PCS max fill is 16 ounces.
So as Joe mentioned, it is heavier - I think about 3oz. overall - but allows for more water.
I'll enjoy seeing what others views are on it, as mine are mostly empirical and based off aesthetics.
A pretty unit, with some nice burner to boiler contact for stability. Looking forward to more info.
I'm interested
ReplyDeleteHi Hendrik, if you have another space I'd like to give the Reactor a test run.
ReplyDeleteRichard
Hi
ReplyDeleteReactor is a lovely lovely piece of kit, it just oozes 'buy me' 'buy me' 'buy me'. So I did. The only negative I could find was the lack of piezo ignition. It really does generate a lot of heat, water seems to boil in an instant. Have fun everyone.
Hi!
ReplyDeleteBack again from the North. Great trip (again) with really pleasant weather!
I'm interested in testing the Reactor!
Hi!
ReplyDeleteI'd really like to test this MSR stove. It's still below zero Celsius before sunrise in Estonia, so it would be great to give it a go in these cinditions.
Priit
Would be honored to try this "rocket" out! Just let me now!
ReplyDeleteWith regards,
Mattias
Interesting stove. I am interested in a another gas stove as I was alarmed at the safety issues raised about the Carbon monoxide issues on BPL about the Eta Solo stove I own. I know there is the recycling issues around gas and need an efficient stove that uses less - and hence less empty canisters is the way to go for me. Seen this video.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.livefortheoutdoors.com/Videos/Search-Results/Camping--backpacking/MSR-Reactor-vs-Jetboil/
Thanks all, the Passaround tester have now been selected: http://www.hikinginfinland.com/2010/04/first-look-msr-reactor-passaround.html
ReplyDeleteMartin, check the above link to a video I made. It seems like an efficient stove to me, though I am no expert on gas stoves.
Hi Hendrik, if you have another space I'd like to give the Reactor a test run.
ReplyDeleteRichard